Two-story home with a brick lower level and covered patio beside an autumn-colored wooded yard.

In Lancaster, the Woods Behind the Lot Aren't Protected Until Someone Records It

October 8, 2026

"It is only labeled as an Exception Lot which does not exclude it from being changed to a buildable lot." That sentence appears in the draft minutes of the Lancaster Planning Board's September 2, 2026 meeting. It is the board's summary of what Ken Zollitsch of GPI, the engineer for DJC Land Development, LLC, told the room after he explained that no deed restrictions had been filed on the property.

The parcel is 13 Silent Meadow Lane in the Hidden Pines Subdivision, Phase 2A. It covers about 0.56 acres. Several homeowners who bought next to it came to the meeting with the papers they had relied on when they bought. For anyone about to buy a home in one of Lancaster's newer subdivisions, the meeting carries one lesson. A preservation area on a marketing map, a lot-availability sheet, or a seller's description has no legal force by itself. What counts is what was recorded with the county, and many buyers never look.

What Happened at 13 Silent Meadow Lane

The draft minutes record each resident's account in some detail. One neighboring homeowner showed a document he had trusted as a guarantee that his home bordered a Preservation Area. Another neighboring homeowner showed a map that he said agents used to show buyers which lots were still for sale, and he said he was told the Preservation Area would not be touched. A neighboring resident described a bulldozer that was dropped off on the lot and later removed. He said residents, with some help from the Town, had maintained the lot over the years, not the developer. A neighboring homeowner said a Forbes representative told her the parcel would stay a preservation lot. Another neighboring resident said the lots were marketed and sold on the understanding that no home could go on that parcel. Every resident who spoke asked the board to deny the change.

Aric Greco of DJC Land Development answered that buyers had been told the truth when they bought. He said the lot now meets code requirements. Both accounts can be true at once. A parcel can be held back from sale for years and still carry no recorded restriction that keeps it open for good.

The Planning Board acts as an advisor to the Lancaster Town Board, which is the lead agency under the State Environmental Quality Review Act. The Planning Board recommended that the Town Board issue a Positive Declaration, finding potential significant adverse impacts. The Town Board's September 8 agenda logged two letters about the site. The Erie County Division of Planning made no recommendation on the zoning referral for 13 Silent Meadow, and NYSDEC responded to the lead-agency request. Neither letter is a decision.

The Town Board took up the lot on September 21, 2026. It first considered a resolution to adopt a Negative Declaration, which would have found no significant adverse environmental impact. All five members voted no. It then considered a resolution to approve converting the exception lot to a building lot. That resolution noted that the Planning Board had made no recommendation to approve or deny the application, only the Positive Declaration recommendation. Council Members Anticola, Burkard, Schroeder and Studley and Supervisor Leary all voted no, so the approval failed. The neighbors kept their view this time through a vote of the Town Board. No recorded restriction played a part, and the next request on a similar lot elsewhere will go before the same kind of discretionary vote. The September 2 Planning Board minutes are also still marked as drafts and may be amended.

Why a Label Can Lose to a Lot That Meets Code

New York law is specific about what makes open space permanent. Under Environmental Conservation Law Article 49, a conservation easement is an interest in real property that limits development or use to preserve scenic, open, or natural values. Such an easement "shall be of perpetual duration unless otherwise provided in such instrument." Recording is the condition that matters for a buyer. Section 49-0305 says an instrument creating, changing, or ending one "shall not be effective unless recorded" in the county land records. The holder also has to be a public body or a qualifying not-for-profit conservation organization. A developer cannot create one by labeling a corner of a site plan.

Private restrictions follow the same rule. New York's recording statute makes an unrecorded conveyance void against a later good-faith buyer whose own deed is recorded first. Lancaster's subdivision rules ask developers to submit draft protective covenants. A draft submitted to the Town is a different thing from a signed covenant filed at the Erie County Clerk's Office. Once something is recorded, it carries weight. Lancaster's zoning law says it does not cancel existing deed or plat restrictions and easements.

What the buyer may see What it actually is Where its force comes from
"Preservation Area" on a sales map Marketing material None by itself
"Exception Lot" on a plan A parcel held out of the lot count None by itself, per the developer's engineer at Hidden Pines
Draft protective covenants A document submitted with the subdivision application Only once signed and recorded
Conservation easement A recorded interest held by a public body or qualifying nonprofit ECL Article 49, perpetual unless the instrument says otherwise
Restriction noted on the filed plat Part of the approved, recorded subdivision map Town approval and recording with the County Clerk

The Same Question, at a Larger Scale, on Bowen Road

Hidden Pines concerns about half an acre. Windsor Ridge South Phase 2 raises the same question across about 117 acres at Bowen and Brunck roads, proposed by Windsor Ridge Partners LLC. At a scoping hearing on November 5, 2025, Sean Hopkins, the applicants' attorney, said the project had been cut from 196 lots to 142. At the same hearing, a resident said a "35 acres conservation area" had been removed from the map. That is her statement as recorded in draft minutes, not a finding by the Town. GPI's representative said property markers and the use of common areas would be discussed.

The process has moved since then, but slowly. A November 20, 2025 NYSDEC letter recommended adding freshwater wetland impacts to the scope of the environmental review. By January 7, 2026, the Planning Board had received an approved Town resolution on the final scoping document. The town record reviewed shows no accepted draft environmental impact statement, no hearing date, and no lot count after 142. Whatever the final plan shows as conservation or common land is still being decided.

That matters for anyone buying in the earlier phases nearby. The Town Board must approve any revision to a plat after it is approved. Lancaster's rules call a recorded revision that skips this step null and void. The New York Department of State's guidance says a resubdivision is reviewed much like an original plat, and that other owners or rights-holders must join or agree. These protections apply to land on a filed plat. Land shown only on a concept drawing has no such protection.

Another proposal is following the same path. Paul Marinaccio is the listed developer for a proposed 96-home subdivision on a former quarry site at 351 Pavement Road, with a 12-acre lake and 36.88 acres of open space in the concept. The September 2 minutes describe a rezoning of 88.13 acres from General Industrial to Residential, with "communal greenspace." The Planning Board recommended a Negative Declaration to the Town Board. That is a recommendation, not final approval of the rezoning. If that project goes ahead, future buyers there will face the same question: who holds the greenspace, and what instrument binds it.

Checking Before the Offer, Not After

The regional market leaves little slack for this kind of research. The Buffalo Niagara Association of Realtors reported a $300,000 median sale price for August 2026 in its Regional Board B area, with homes averaging 17 days on market. That figure covers the region, not Lancaster alone. Inventory in that area was up 20% from a year earlier, which gives buyers somewhat more room. Still, an attractive lot backing onto woods rarely waits while a buyer researches records for the first time.

The steps below follow the county's own instructions:

  1. Start with the parcel, not the street address. The Erie County Clerk says its records search is not indexed by street address. You first use the county's parcel search to find the owner and the deed book and page.
  2. Search by map number and parcel ID as well as by name. The Clerk's online records search supports party, document type, instrument number, book and page, map number, and parcel ID. Party searches take last name, then first name, with no comma.
  3. Plan to request the actual document. Online users can see document information but not the images. Copies can be requested, and public terminals are available at the Clerk's Office.
  4. Ask which map you are looking at. Lancaster's rules separate an unrecorded sketch plan from a final plat. Proposed open space and dedications are shown in the plan materials, and a plat can be recorded only after approval. A sales map may match neither one.
  5. Find out who holds it. If a seller or builder says the land is protected, ask who holds the easement or covenant and for its recording reference. A conservation easement needs a qualifying holder.
  6. Bring the question to your attorney early. The New York State Bar Association describes the buyer's attorney ordering a title report and explaining its exceptions, including easements, covenants, or restrictions. Ask specifically about the neighboring parcel, since the title report on your own lot may not answer it.

Hidden Pines also shows the limits of these records. A buyer told the board his attorney had advised against buying, and that he went ahead after being told the next-door lot would not be built on. What the record shows only protects a buyer who reads it before closing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is "exception lot" a legal designation? In the Hidden Pines record, the developer's engineer described it as a label with no deed restriction behind it. He said the label did not prevent the lot from being converted to a buildable one. The recorded documents for any given parcel are the only reliable answer.

Does title insurance cover a change to the lot next door? The NYSBA says title insurance may protect against financial loss but does not replace counsel. It also says the policy's terms, exceptions, and limitations should be reviewed by an attorney. Ask your attorney how your own policy applies.

What about parkland the Town requires? State Town Law §277 lets a planning board require parkland on a residential plat after making a finding about recreational need. Where no suitable park can be placed on the plat, the board can require a payment into a fund restricted to park and recreation uses. Land dedicated through that process differs from a parcel a developer simply leaves unsold.

When a listing in a Lancaster subdivision says it borders open space, The Macey Team can help you trace that claim to the filed plat and the recorded instrument before you write an offer, and connect you with an attorney who will read them closely. Let's Connect.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Brennan

Brennan combines industry experience, financial insight, and a client-focused approach to help you navigate every step of your real estate journey.