Brick-and-siding ranch entrance with a concrete walk, autumn lawn and two hydrangeas beneath a broad window.

Cheektowaga's Proposed Town Tax Increase Is the Smaller Line on Your Bill

October 29, 2026

Cheektowaga's proposed 2027 budget would add about $201 to the town bill on an average home. Two houses in the same town, with the same assessment, can already be more than $1,100 apart on their school taxes alone. For anyone pricing a home here this fall, the debate at Town Hall matters. The district lines a house sits inside matter more.

In Cheektowaga, town and county bills and school bills arrive at two different points in the year. Town and county bills went out in January 2026, with penalty-free payment through February 17. School bills for 2026–27 were mailed September 15, 2026 and were due by October 15.

What the 2027 town budget would change

Supervisor Brian Nowak filed his tentative 2027 budget on September 30. It would raise the townwide tax levy 9.8%, from $75.5 million to $82.9 million. The Cheektowaga Bee reported that for a house assessed at $155,400, the town average, the total town bill would rise from $1,881 to $2,083.

That town bill has three parts, and they don't behave alike:

Component 2026 Proposed 2027
Ad valorem town tax $1,434 $1,616
Drainage fee $6.39 $9.08
Sewer consumption fee $440.94 $458.58
Total town bill $1,881 $2,083

Figures for a home assessed at $155,400, as reported by the Cheektowaga Bee.

The biggest dollar increase in the budget is in the Consolidated Sewer District levy. It rises 26.5%, from $13.5 million to $17.1 million. The reason is a funding change more than new spending. The 2026 adopted budget drew $3 million from the district's fund balance, and the 2027 plan draws $300,000. Nowak said his 2026 proposal called for a 7.6% levy increase and that the board rejected it. In practice, reserves held part of the 2026 bill down. A seller's January 2026 town bill shows that cushioned figure.

The sewer charge also works differently from the rest of the bill. On the 2026 final assessment roll it appears as a flat "Consol sewer 441.00 SU" charge per unit, with no link to assessed value. At the average assessment, that fee was already close to a quarter of the 2026 town bill. On a lower-assessed home, the same flat dollar amount is a larger share of the total.

The plan is not final yet. In October the Town Board adopted Local Law No. 9 of 2026 by a 5–2 vote. It lets the town exceed the state tax cap, and it needed a 60% supermajority. The Bee's coverage of that vote notes that the law only authorizes a budget above the cap. It does not adopt one. The preliminary budget hearing was scheduled for Tuesday, October 27. A final budget must be adopted by November 20, and the board can still amend the tentative plan. Finance Director Brian Krause had told residents at a January hearing that he believed Cheektowaga was the only Western New York town of its size that had not exceeded the cap since the law took effect in 2012.

Eight school districts inside one town

For school taxes, Cheektowaga is divided among eight districts, and each sets its own rate for the Cheektowaga part of its territory. The town's school tax notice lists bills for Cheektowaga Central, Cheektowaga-Maryvale, Cheektowaga-Sloan, Cleveland Hill, Depew, Lancaster, West Seneca, and Williamsville.

Erie County's 2026–2027 school tax rate table lists each district's rate for its Cheektowaga portion. Applied to the same $155,400 assessment, before any exemptions:

School district, Cheektowaga portion 2026–27 rate per $1,000 assessed School tax at $155,400
Lancaster $12.22 about $1,900
West Seneca $14.78 about $2,297
Cheektowaga Central $14.83 about $2,305
Williamsville $15.06 about $2,340
Cheektowaga-Maryvale $15.15 about $2,355
Depew $16.29 about $2,531
Cleveland Hill $18.28 about $2,840
Cheektowaga-Sloan $19.61 about $3,048

The highest and lowest rates are about $1,148 a year apart on identical assessments. That is more than five times the proposed town increase on the average home, and it comes from the address, not from any budget vote. The rate differences are also mostly settled. The school bills reflecting them were mailed in September. Several districts' 2026–27 budgets carried proposed levy increases between roughly 1% and 3%. Cheektowaga-Sloan proposed 0.98%, Cleveland Hill 1.95%, Depew 2.17%, Cheektowaga Central 2.72%, and Williamsville 3.14%. Those are small moves compared with the gaps between districts.

A second map, drawn by fire districts

Fire protection adds another layer of boundaries. Erie County's 2026 Annual Report lists nine Cheektowaga fire districts, each with its own rate. Applied to a $155,400 assessment, the 2026 rates range from about $190 in U-Crest to about $305 in Walden.

  • U-Crest: $1.22 per $1,000, about $190
  • Cleveland Hill: $1.27, about $198
  • South Line: $1.42, about $221
  • Forks: $1.45, about $225
  • Hy-View: $1.50, about $233
  • Bellevue: $1.54, about $240
  • Pine Hill: $1.79, about $278
  • Doyle: $1.80, about $280
  • Walden: $1.96, about $305

These are 2026 rates, and fire districts set 2027 budgets on their own schedules. The Forks Fire District, for example, scheduled its proposed-budget hearing for October 20. A spread of about $115 is modest alone. Combined with the school district, it means two houses with the same assessment on opposite sides of town can differ by well over $1,200 a year before the town budget is counted.

Why the assessment isn't the price, and the rates don't travel

The $155,400 figure is an assessed value, not a sale price. Erie County's 2026 report puts Cheektowaga's equalization rate at 75.00.

This matters most to buyers comparing Cheektowaga with nearby towns. The Lancaster Central School District charges $12.22 per $1,000 on its Cheektowaga portion and about $9.04 on its Town of Lancaster portion in the same 2026–27 table. It is one school district with one budget, but the rate per $1,000 differs because each town assesses at a different share of market value. A rate per $1,000 means little across a town line until it is applied to a specific assessment on a specific roll.

What to request before an offer

Each house's own records answer these questions, and most of them are public:

  1. Find the parcel on the town's assessment roll. Cheektowaga's 2026 final roll lists each property's assessed value, its fire district, and its sewer unit charge.
  2. Confirm the school district for tax purposes.
  3. Ask for both of the seller's actual bills: the January 2026 town/county bill and the September 2026 school bill. Note any exemptions on them, and ask the town assessor whether each one would apply to a new owner.
  4. Check whether the home is in a village. Parts of Cheektowaga are in the Village of Depew or the Village of Sloan, and both levy village taxes.

This is general information, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Exemptions, escrow amounts, and your actual tax liability should be confirmed with your attorney, lender, or a tax professional.

Frequently Asked Questions

When will the 2027 Cheektowaga town budget be final? The Bee reports that a final budget must be adopted by November 20, 2026. The board can amend Nowak's tentative plan before then, so the 9.8% levy increase and the $201 estimate are proposals until adoption.

When would the new town budget first be reflected in a bill? Town and county bills in Cheektowaga are issued in mid-January. In 2026, collection began January 15. The January 2027 bill would be the first to reflect whatever budget the board adopts.

Does a higher school tax rate mean a higher total bill? Not necessarily. Town, county, fire, and any village charges also affect the total.

Work With Brennan

Brennan combines industry experience, financial insight, and a client-focused approach to help you navigate every step of your real estate journey.